A Comparison of Engineering Polyacetals

Acetal, chemically known as Polyoxymethylene (POM), is a high-performance engineering thermoplastic favoured for its high stiffness, low friction, and excellent dimensional stability. In industrial applications, engineers typically specify between two variants: Acetal C (Copolymer) and Acetal H (Homopolymer). While they share a common name, their molecular structures lead to distinct performance characteristics.

Mechanical Properties and Performance

Acetal H, often recognised by the brand name Delrin®, is produced by the polymerisation of formaldehyde. This results in a higher degree of crystallinity than its copolymer counterpart. Consequently, Acetal H offers superior mechanical strength, hardness, and creep resistance. It is approximately 10–15% stronger than Acetal C and exhibits better fatigue endurance under cyclic loading.

Conversely, Acetal C is formed through the copolymerisation of trioxane with a comonomer. This slightly "disrupted" molecular chain reduces crystallinity but provides better long-term stability. While it lacks the sheer tensile strength of Acetal H, Acetal C is more resistant to thermal-oxidative degradation and maintains its properties more effectively when exposed to high temperatures over extended periods.

Fabrication and Ease of Processing

Both materials are highly regarded for their "free-machining" qualities, producing small, manageable chips rather than long stringy swarf. This makes them ideal for high-speed CNC milling and turning. However, Acetal H is generally slightly easier to machine to extremely tight tolerances because of its higher surface hardness and rigidity.

A notable drawback of Acetal H is "centre-line porosity"—a density inconsistency that occurs during the extrusion of large-diameter rods or thick plates. This can lead to structural weaknesses or leakage in manifold applications. Acetal C is virtually free from centre-line porosity, making it the superior choice for components where internal integrity and gas-tightness are critical.

Bonding and Assembly

Acetal is notoriously difficult to bond due to its high solvent resistance and low surface energy. Standard adhesives often fail to "wet" the surface. While both types require aggressive surface pre-treatment - such as flame treatment, chromic acid etching, or plasma discharge - Acetal C tends to respond slightly better to chemical etching. For permanent assemblies, mechanical fastening or ultrasonic welding are the preferred industrial methods, with Acetal H providing a marginally stiffer joint.

Chemical Resistance

Acetal C is significantly more resistant to strong alkalis and hot water (hydrolysis) than Acetal H. In environments with a pH value greater than 9, Acetal H is prone to degradation, whereas Acetal C remains stable. Furthermore, the copolymer variant is less susceptible to scaling and is preferred for use with chlorinated water, which can cause premature failure in homopolymer grades.

Practical Applications

Due to its high tensile strength, Acetal H is typically selected for high-load mechanical components such as small-diameter gears, bearings, and fasteners where maximum rigidity is paramount. It is also found in consumer goods like zips and aerosol valves.

Acetal C is the preferred choice for the food and beverage industry, plumbing components, and medical devices. Its lack of porosity and resistance to cleaning agents make it ideal for valves, pumps, and manifolds where fluid containment and hygiene are essential.

Recyclability and Sustainability

Both materials are 100% recyclable thermoplastics. They can be granulated and reformed without significant degradation. However, Acetal C is considered "friendlier" for recycling due to its wider processing window. Acetal H is more sensitive to overheating, requiring tighter controls to prevent the release of formaldehyde gas during re-melting.

Summary - Key Differences

While Acetal H is the specialist for high-stress mechanical parts, Acetal C remains the versatile all-rounder for chemically demanding or hot-water environments.

Plastock supplies Acetal C and Acetal H rods and sheets in an extensive range of sizes, colours and  grades, including filled, anti-static and electrically conductive variants, all available with quick delivery from UK stock.

Click the button below to check out the range...